Sens (Yonne, France) - Cathedral of Saint-Étienne
- Disclaimer
The dating found here is based on the work of John James, and is meant on this site to serve as a starting point. James' dating is derived from a system that uses his interpretation of the development of capitals over time as the basis for chronology, among other factors. His goal is to refine the dating to within years rather than decades. I have not fully embraced James' methodology, and will be developing this page from its current state to one which is admittedly more conservative. The relative expenditure values found in the Timeline are also based on James' work, and I believe these to be reasonably reliable. They are intended only to give a sense of the amount of work involved in each decade.
I have added the idea of the "project" as a way of separating work in buildings. In my mind, a "project" is a discrete section of work in a building that resulted from the one-time acquisition of funding. "Projects" are generally separated by at least a decade where no work was being done. It is my view that it would have been unwise to start a "project" that could not be finished and protected from the elements, and as such a "project" usually involved a wing or multiple wings of a building, from floor to roof. Rural churches, which could only secure small amounts of funding at irregular intervals, often were the result of many small projects, while the great churches, which benefitted from relatively consistent funding, may have involved only a few large projects.
I have added the idea of the "project" as a way of separating work in buildings. In my mind, a "project" is a discrete section of work in a building that resulted from the one-time acquisition of funding. "Projects" are generally separated by at least a decade where no work was being done. It is my view that it would have been unwise to start a "project" that could not be finished and protected from the elements, and as such a "project" usually involved a wing or multiple wings of a building, from floor to roof. Rural churches, which could only secure small amounts of funding at irregular intervals, often were the result of many small projects, while the great churches, which benefitted from relatively consistent funding, may have involved only a few large projects.
- Timeline with Relative Expenditure (if available, in building units)
- Project A - 1130s - Phase 1 - church (b)
The size and consistency shows that all bases for the walls and piers were laid down at the one time, from east to penultimate pier 13 in the west; this included the lateral chapels; afterwards average rate of construction across the site seems to have been in the order of 5 or so courses per year.
- Project A - 1130s - Phase 2 - choir (d)
Choir and north chapel dado capitals; rebuilding has eliminated the evidence for how far this stage of the work was continued to the west; and very wide windows around the ambulatory.
- Project A - 1130s - Phase 3 - choir piers (a)
This is a test
- Project A - 1130s - Phase 4 - choir walls (a)
Ambulatory pier capitals for groin vaults
- Project A - 1140s - Phase 5 - stalls
A temporary roof may have been erected at this level to cover the eastern choir; the wooden stalls were built under this and on his death Bishop Henry was interred in the choir in 1144.
- Project A - 1150s - Phase 6 - w nave (d)
Nave dado probably in more than one campaign
- Project A - 1150s - Phase 7 - choir (a) 1-4
The four choir piers from today's crossing to the east; from the style of the capitals continued into the nave to piers 6; once the aisle vaults were completed this huge undertaking would be sufficient to support all future stages in the gallery and clerestory.
- Project A - 1150s - Phase 8 - nave (a) 1-6
From the style of the capitals the same crew working in the choir continued into the nave to pier 6, leaving only the piers under the towers to be finished later; ten piers (plus one in the centre transept).
- Project A - 1160s - Phase 9 - east (av)
The continuation of corbels to support the aisle ribs from the ambulatory to the doubleau of the 6th pier west of the crossing shows the extent of the work when it was decided to use rib vaults; that the smaller corbels of this phase sit over the capitals of both Phases 1 and 2 of the southern choir aisle capitals shows how far the works had proceeded before this decision was made; the corbels in the choir are smaller than those in the nave and have an additional larger course between it and the rib.
- Project A - 1160s - Phase 10 - west (av)
The corbels in the nave to the doubleau of the 6th pier; these sit over the capitals of Phase 2; in the west side of the 6th aisle pier the style of the formeret capital and the corbels show this to have been part of the later works in the west; whatever had been constructed on the south wall was replaced after the collapse.
- Project A - 1160s - Phase 11 - choir (gb)
Walling over arcade arches and choir gallery walkway
- Project A - 1160s - Phase 12 - choir (g,c) 1-7
Choir gallery capitals
- Project A - 1160s - Phase 13 - choir (c)
Choir clerestory capitals
- Project A - 1160s - Phase 14 - flyers 1-7
Install the first flyers 1-7 and roof in place immediately afterwards.
- Project A - 1160s - Phase 15 - choir (cw)
Choir wall above flyers 1-7 for domical vault form.
- Project A - 1160s - Phase 16 - choir (rc)
Roof cornice with details like those in Canterbury by William of Sens.
- Project A - 1170s - Phase 17 - nave 6-8 (a)
Nave arcade capitals 6-8.
- Project A - 1170s - Phase 18 - nave 3-7 (g,c)
Mid-nave gallery
- Project A - 1170s - Phase 19 - w portals (b)
West portals begun with western nave bay,
- Project A - 1170s - Phase 20 - nave (a) 13-14
Western nave aisle capitals
- Project A - 1170s - Phase 21 - nave (v) 11-14
Nave aisle vaults 11-14
- Project A - 1170s - Phase 22 - mid-nave (c+)
Nave-mid clerestory flyers
- Project A - 1180s - Phase 23 - portals
Probably after the fire of 1184; as portal joints mismatched probably carved in shed before it was needed
- Project A - 1180s - Phase 24 - e nave (v)
Eastern nave vaults and flyers 8-12
- Project A - 1190s - Phase 25 - w nave (g)
West aisle bays to gallery
- Project A - 1200s - Phase 26 - w nave (c)
West clerestory,
- Project A - 1210s - Phase 27 - tower rooms
Tower rooms in the one campaign
- Primary Sources for Dating
1125 or later - SENS
Work begun
Work begun
For the church of Saint-Etienne, for which the good Henri began and has nearly completed the work. Of the solid oak stalls of the choir which which he has managed to make and are nearly completed; he has given many ornaments to the church,…
1144 - SENS
Stalls nearing completion
Stalls nearing completion
In the year of the Incarnation 1144, Lord Hugo had done…numerous works at the church of Saint-Etienne were begun by good Henri which have nearly been completed. He made possible solid oak stalls in the choir which are nearly finished. He gave numerous ornaments to the church; and in the presence of the canons he visited the relics, and gave them an honorable place.
1164, April 19 - SENS
Consecration by Pope Alexander III
Consecration by Pope Alexander III
…consecrated this altar in the new church.
1164, April 19 - SENS
Consecration by Pope Alexander III
Consecration by Pope Alexander III
…the following year, at the request of archbishop Hugh and the clerics of the church, he consecrated for them this altar in honor of the blessed apostles Peter and Paul in the new church the 19th of April,…
1168 - SENS
Completion of the church
Completion of the church
The church…was brought to fruition.
1184 - SENS
Fire
Fire
All of the town of Sens and the mother church was greatly and in every way weakened by fire.
1184, June 23 - SENS
Fire
Fire
In the year of our lord 1184, on the eve of the feast of John the Baptist, the city of Sens burned along with the church of the protomartyr Stephen and many men and women.
Date ? - SENS
Gold and silver were heaped before the altar of Saint-Etienne, after which towers of great height were made at the front of the church.