Saint-Denis-en-France (Seine-St-Denis, France) - Saint-Denis
- Disclaimer
The dating found here is based on the work of John James, and is meant on this site to serve as a starting point. James' dating is derived from a system that uses his interpretation of the development of capitals over time as the basis for chronology, among other factors. His goal is to refine the dating to within years rather than decades. I have not fully embraced James' methodology, and will be developing this page from its current state to one which is admittedly more conservative. The relative expenditure values found in the Timeline are also based on James' work, and I believe these to be reasonably reliable. They are intended only to give a sense of the amount of work involved in each decade.
I have added the idea of the "project" as a way of separating work in buildings. In my mind, a "project" is a discrete section of work in a building that resulted from the one-time acquisition of funding. "Projects" are generally separated by at least a decade where no work was being done. It is my view that it would have been unwise to start a "project" that could not be finished and protected from the elements, and as such a "project" usually involved a wing or multiple wings of a building, from floor to roof. Rural churches, which could only secure small amounts of funding at irregular intervals, often were the result of many small projects, while the great churches, which benefitted from relatively consistent funding, may have involved only a few large projects.
I have added the idea of the "project" as a way of separating work in buildings. In my mind, a "project" is a discrete section of work in a building that resulted from the one-time acquisition of funding. "Projects" are generally separated by at least a decade where no work was being done. It is my view that it would have been unwise to start a "project" that could not be finished and protected from the elements, and as such a "project" usually involved a wing or multiple wings of a building, from floor to roof. Rural churches, which could only secure small amounts of funding at irregular intervals, often were the result of many small projects, while the great churches, which benefitted from relatively consistent funding, may have involved only a few large projects.
- Timeline with Relative Expenditure (if available, in building units)
- Project A - Earlier - Phase 1 - crypt
Merovingian crypt under choir and outline remains of previous nave
- Project B - 1120s - Phase 2 - narthex (b)
Narthex foundations dug some 9 courses into the soil; the bases were 12-13 courses lower, and were raised in the C19; on average construction continued at about 8 courses per year until completion
- Project B - 1120s - Phase 3 - w portal 1
- Project B - 1130s - Phase 4 - w portal 2
West portals stage 2 lateral capitals and imposts; incomplete designs in upper panels indicate that the height of the lateral portals had been reduced a few centimetres after the panels had been carved; differences in levels with central portal discussed in MCS#04 "Jerome"
- Project B - 1130s - Phase 5 - w portal 3
West portals stage 3 central capitals and imposts and start of erection of lateral archivolts; the intended height of the central portal was considerably reduced on erection as can be seen in the curtailed canopies over the upper jamb figures that had been carved earlier, as well as the adjacent right capital.
- Project B - 1130s - Phase 6 - w portal 4
- Project B - 1130s - Phase 7 - narthex aisle (a-)
- Project B - 1130s - Phase 9 - narthex aisle (a)
- Project B - 1130s - Phase 11 - narthex clerestory (c)
Capitals for central vaults placed with erection of the arcade arches and ghe walkway on the west wall over the central portal which would have been complete by then
- Project B - 1130s - Phase 13 - narthex aisle windows
Completion of aisle windows set well into the cells of the vaults and therefore constructed at the same time, and with the external frieze over the central portal; sill to the west window that may be one of the widest consgtructed to this time
- Project B - 1140s - Phase 15 - narthex raised vault
- Project B - 1130s - Phase 17 - narthex w walkway
Shafts and capitals on each side of the western walkway and stairs to the towers; the string courses underneath the lateral openings into the towers have different profiles and are at different levels suggesting a number of campaigns at this level
- Project B - 1130s - Phase 19 - narthex responds (c+)
In eastern clerestory bay capitals were added under the responds; floor level of the towers in which the west walls were raised higher than the side walls, presumably to provide lateral support for the rose window.
- Project B - 1140s - Phase 21 - narthex side openings
- Project B - 1140s - Phase 23 - west exterior
- Project B - 1140s - Phase 25 - narthex upper chapel (b)
Chapel floor level established with walls and start of rose window over western frieze
- Project B - 1130s - Phase 27 - narthex upper chapel (a)
Springing for chapel ribs with impost carried around piers
- Project B - 1130s - Phase 29 - narthex upper chapel (aw)
Chapel openings with capitals and arches, arches for the vaults and wall around rose half way up
- Project B - 1130s - Phase 31 - west towers (w)
- Project B - 1140s - Phase 33 - choir (b)
Choir foundations and bases, possibly begun earlier, with evidence for at least two, if not three, crews in the lowest courses
- Project B - 1140s - Phase 34 - choir (u)
Choir crypt, capitals early in 1141 MCS #8:11
- Project B - 1140s - Phase 35 - choir walls (a)
Ambulatory walls for a single passage and deep chapels; window sills and wall capitals alongside windows; evidence discussed in James "Gesta" 1989
- Project B - 1140s - Phase 36 - double ambulatory
Choir redesigned for a double ambulatory, rib shafts and higher capitals for the doubleau arches
- Project B - 1140s - Phase 37 - choir drums (a)
Choir intermediate piers; capitals carved by a separate crew to the
- Project B - 1140s - Phase 38 - choir windows
Chapel window arches and external capitals
- Project B - 1140s - Phase 39 - choir (rc)
Choir cornice with the completion of the aisle vaults; there is no evidence that work continued above this level; as in the narthex the construciton rate was about 8 courses each year.
- Project B - 1140s - Phase 40 - n portal 1
- Project C - 1160s - Phase 41 - e tower I
East tower I
- Project C - 1160s - Phase 42 - n portal 2
North portal stage 2
- Project D - 1230s - Phase 43 - choir (a)
Replace choir piers with drums, build transepts walls
- Project D - 1240s - Phase 44 - nave (a)
Nave and transept dado, aisle walls and vaults
- Project D - 1240s - Phase 45 - south-s
South transept door
- Primary Sources for Dating
- S-DEN-FR
Time needed to construct the choir
Time needed to construct the choir
For three years we pressed the completion of the work at great expense, with a numerous crowd of workmen, summer and winter,…
1140, June 9 - S-DEN-FR
Western chapel of St. Romanus above narthex dedicated
Western chapel of St. Romanus above narthex dedicated
We brought about that the chapel of St. Romanus be dedicated…How secluded this place is, how hallowed, how convenient for those celebrating the divine rights has come to be known to those who serve God there as though they were already dwelling, in a degree, in Heaven while they sacrifice.
1144, June 11 - S-DEN-FR
Choir consecrated.
Choir consecrated.
It allowed that whole magnificent building {to be completed} in three years and three months, from the crypt below to the summit of the vaults above, elaborated with the variety of so many arches and columns, including even the consummation of the roof…The year was the one thousand, one hundred, forty and fourth of the Word when [the choir] was consecrated.
1231 - S-DEN-FR
Reconstruction required.
Reconstruction required.
…for repairs to our church, which through use and iNevitably threatening ruin.